Is a High Dividend Yield Good? 3 Checks Before You Invest
Last Updated on 3 weeks ago by Antony C.
A high dividend yield looks attractive, especially when you are trying to build passive income.
But I never assume a 10% yield is better than a 5% yield just because the number is bigger. Before I invest, I want to understand where that extra income is coming from and whether it can last.
Quick Takeaways
- A high dividend yield does not automatically mean a better investment.
- Sometimes the yield is high simply because the share price has fallen.
- A dividend or distribution can be reduced in the future.
- I look at both the income and what is happening to my capital.
- Before chasing yield, I ask why it is high, whether it is sustainable, and what I may be giving up for that extra income.
Disclaimer: I may or may not have invest in any of the stocks/REITs/ETFs, what’s listed here is only for entertainment purpose only and it should never be used as any form of investment advice. Past performance ≠ future results. While I’ve been investing for +15 years, I am still learning, this is my stock investment diary, and I wish to share what I learn during my investment journey so you may learn from both my success and mistakes. Enjoy!
Why a 10% Dividend Yield Looks So Attractive
Let us start with a simple example.
If you invest $10,000:
| Dividend Yield | Approx. Annual Income |
|---|---|
| 5% | $500 |
| 10% | $1,000 |
If your goal is to eventually build $1,000 a month in dividend income, the 10% investment looks much more attractive.
You appear to get twice the income from the same amount of capital.
That is why high-yield investments can be hard to ignore.
But dividend yield only tells us how much income an investment pays compared with its current price. It does not tell us whether that income will continue or whether the investment itself is healthy.
That is where my three checks come in.
1. Why Is the Dividend Yield So High?
The first thing I check is the reason behind the high yield.
Dividend yield is calculated as:
Annual Dividend ÷ Current Share Price × 100
This means the yield can increase even when the dividend does not.
Suppose a company pays $5 in dividends per share each year.
At a share price of $100, the yield is: $5 ÷ $100 = 5%
If the share price falls to $50 while the dividend stays at $5: $5 ÷ $50 = 10%
The company did not suddenly become more generous.
Its share price fell by half.
This Can Be a Dividend Yield Trap
A falling share price is not always bad. Sometimes a good investment simply becomes cheaper.
But there may also be a reason investors are selling.
For example:
- Profits may be falling.
- Cash flow may be getting weaker.
- Debt may be increasing.
- The business may be facing serious problems.
- Investors may expect the dividend to be cut.
This is sometimes called a dividend yield trap.
The high yield catches your attention, but the underlying investment may be getting weaker.
So when I see an unusually high dividend yield, my first question
- It is not: “How much income can I earn?“
- It is: “Why has the yield become this high?“
That small change in thinking can help us avoid chasing a number without understanding what sits behind it.
2. Can the Dividend Continue?
The next thing I want to know is whether the payout is sustainable.
Dividends are not guaranteed.
A company needs enough earnings and cash flow to keep paying shareholders. For REITs and income funds, I also want to understand where the distributions are coming from and whether that source can continue.
This matters because the yield you see today is not necessarily the yield you will receive next year.
What Happens If a 10% Dividend Is Cut?
Suppose you invest $10,000 into an investment showing a 10% yield.
You may expect around: $10,000 × 10% = $1,000 a year
But if the dividend is later cut by half, your expected income falls to about $500.
You are now receiving roughly the income you might have expected from a 5% yield.
The difference is that you may have taken considerably more risk to get there.
A dividend cut can also hurt the share price because income investors may lose confidence and sell.
That means you could be hit twice:
- Lower dividend income
- Lower investment value
For me, this is why dividend sustainability matters more than the headline yield.
What I Check Before Trusting the Dividend
I do not rely on one ratio or number to tell me whether a dividend is safe.
Instead, I try to understand a few basic areas.
Earnings
Is the business earning enough money to support what it pays shareholders?
A company may temporarily pay more than it earns, but that becomes difficult to sustain over a long period.
Cash Flow
Profit on paper does not always mean cash is coming into the business.
I therefore also want to see whether the company generates enough actual cash to fund its dividend.
Dividend Payout Ratio
The dividend payout ratio shows how much of a company’s earnings are being paid as dividends.
It can be useful, but I would not apply the same rule to every investment.
For example, Singapore REITs are structured differently from normal companies and naturally distribute a large portion of their income.
The better approach is to compare similar investments and understand how their payouts work.
Debt
Debt can become especially important when interest rates are high.
A company or REIT with heavy borrowing may need more cash to service its debt, leaving less room for dividends or distributions.
Again, I am not looking for one perfect number.
I simply want to know whether there is a reasonable financial foundation behind the income I am expecting to receive.
3. What Is Happening to My Capital?
This is the part dividend investors can easily overlook.
When I see dividends coming into my account, it feels like progress.
But I also want to know what is happening to the money I invested in the first place.
Suppose you invest $10,000 and receive $1,000 in dividends during the year.
That sounds good.
But your investment is worth only $8,000 at the end of the year.
| What Happened | Amount |
|---|---|
| Starting investment | $10,000 |
| Dividend income | +$1,000 |
| Ending investment value | $8,000 |
| Change in capital value | -$2,000 |
The $1,000 dividend is real.
But so is the $2,000 decline in market value.
This does not mean the $2,000 is permanently lost. The price may recover later.
The point is simply that dividend income should not be viewed on its own.
Look at the Bigger Picture: Total Return
One useful concept here is total return.
In simple terms, total return looks at both:
- The income you received
- The change in the value of your investment
Consider these two simplified investments:
| Investment A | Investment B | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting investment | $10,000 | $10,000 |
| Dividend income | $500 | $1,000 |
| Ending value | $10,500 | $8,000 |
| Dividend yield | 5% | 10% |
If we only look at dividend income, Investment B wins easily.
But once we include what happened to the capital, the answer is no longer so obvious.
This is especially important for those of us investing for long-term passive income.
I do not need my investment value to rise every year. Markets move up and down.
But if an investment keeps paying me a high yield while its underlying value falls year after year, I want to understand why.
I Think of It as a Cash-Flow Machine
I like thinking about my dividend investments as a cash-flow machine.
I put capital into the machine, and over time I hope it produces income for me.
Naturally, I want the income to grow.
But I also want the machine itself to remain healthy.
If it keeps giving me cash while slowly wearing itself down, I may not be making as much progress as I think.
This is why I care about more than just the dividend percentage shown on my brokerage app.
The real question is whether the income and the underlying investment can work together over the long term.
Does This Mean High Dividend Yield Is Bad?
No.
A high dividend yield can still be perfectly reasonable.
Some investments naturally offer more income because they come with different risks or give up some potential growth in exchange for higher cash flow.
That trade-off may suit an investor who values income today.
This is common when comparing different types of investments, such as dividend stocks, REITs, and income-focused ETFs.
A lower yield is not automatically safer either.
A company paying 2% can still be a bad investment, just as an investment yielding 8% can sometimes be sustainable.
So I do not use rules like “High yield = bad“, or “Low yield = good“
The yield is simply one piece of information.
My Simple 3-Check Framework
When I see an attractive dividend yield, this is the framework I use:
| Check | Question | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Yield | Why is the yield so high? | A falling price can make the yield look more attractive |
| 2. Sustainability | Can the payout continue? | Today’s dividend may not survive |
| 3. Capital | What is happening to my investment value? | More income may not help if the underlying investment keeps declining |
I find this much more useful than simply comparing which investment pays 5%, 8%, or 10%.
The highest number does not automatically win.
What About High-Yield REITs and ETFs?
For Singapore and Hong Kong investors, high yields are not limited to individual dividend stocks.
We may also come across REITs, dividend ETFs, covered-call ETFs and other income-focused funds offering attractive distributions.
The same three questions still apply, but I may look at slightly different things.
With a REIT, I may pay closer attention to:
- Rental or property income
- Debt levels
- Interest costs
- Occupancy
- Distribution sustainability
With an income ETF, I want to understand how the fund generates its distributions.
For example, some covered-call ETFs generate part of their income by selling options. That can produce higher cash distributions, but there may also be a trade-off in how much upside the fund captures when markets rise.
There is nothing automatically wrong with that.
I just want to understand what I am giving up in exchange for the higher income.
A Quick Checklist Before Chasing Yield
When I find an investment with a very attractive yield, these are some of the questions I ask:
- Why is the yield higher than similar investments?
- Has the share price fallen sharply?
- Why did the price fall?
- Has the dividend been stable?
- Are earnings and cash flow supporting the payout?
- Is debt becoming a problem?
- How has the investment value changed over time?
- What am I giving up to receive the higher yield?
You do not need every answer to be perfect.
Investing always involves trade-offs.
The goal is simply to understand those trade-offs before putting your money in.
Here’s What I Think About High Yields
I like dividend income, but I do not want to chase yield for the sake of getting a bigger number.
Whenever I see a high dividend yield, I ask three simple questions:
- Why is it high?
- Can the payout continue?
- What is happening to my capital?
A sustainable 5% yield can sometimes be much more useful than a 10% yield that disappears a year later.
For me, the goal is not to find the investment with the highest yield. It is to build a reliable cash-flow machine that can keep working for years.
- Claim up to $1,418 Worth of Free Stocks + Cash Coupon*
- Free SGX & HKEX real-time LV1 quotes
- MAS Regulated Broker (Licence No. CMS101211).
- Lifetime $0 commission fee* for SG, HK & US stocks.
Longbridge Promo: Free Stock + $0 Commission
- Claim up to S$1,200* worth of Free Stocks + Trading Option Gifts + Exclusive Bonus.
- Earn a return on idle cash with Moomoo Cash Plus
- Low commission fee for SG & HK stocks, ETFs & options.
- Lifetime $0 commission free* for US stocks.
Moomoo Promo: Low Commission + Free Stock
Frequently Asked Questions
Disclaimer: The information on this page is for your convenience only. By accessing this website you’ve agree on our T&C. We do not offer tax or investing advisory or brokerage services, nor do we recommend or advise anyone to buy or sell particular stocks, securities or other investments.
21
Brokerage Reviewed & Analyzed
Driven by data, run by investors with real-world experience investing with our own money.
We’re supported by readers who buy via links on our site. While this may influence which products we write, it will not influence our opinions and evaluation. Learn more.
Antony C. is a Singaporean dividend investor focused on building passive income through REITs, ETFs, and Dividend Stocks. With 15+ years of experience investing in Singapore, Hong Kong, and China markets, he founded IncomeBuddies.com to share practical wealth-building strategies tested in his own portfolio since 2008. His expertise has been featured in Yahoo Finance, Nasdaq, and NFAA, and he’s the published book author of "Start Small, Dream Big".